人类学学报 ›› 2015, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (04): 442-450.

• 人类学学报 • 上一篇    下一篇

元谋人”的年龄及相关的年代问题讨论

高星   

  • 出版日期:2015-12-15 发布日期:2015-12-15

On the Age of Homo erectus yuanmounensis and Related Issues

GAO Xing   

  • Online:2015-12-15 Published:2015-12-15

摘要: 五十年前在云南元谋盆地发现的2枚早期直立人牙齿被作为东亚最早的人类化石而载入史册。最初的岩性地层、古生物和古地磁研究确定"元谋人"化石出自早更新世地层,年代为1.70 Ma BP左右,并在以后成为主流意见。但少数学者对此提出了质疑并开展再研究,提出"元谋人"的年代为0.60 Ma~0.70 Ma BP。围绕此问题的最新古地磁研究结果重新肯定了"元谋人"为1.70 Ma BP的结论。从地质、古生物和年代测定各方面的综合材料和数据看,"元谋人"为早更新世早期的结论是可信的。但由于当时化石采集和发掘工作的局限性,这2枚牙齿的确切出土位置和埋藏状况并非十分清晰,"伴生"的文化遗存也十分模糊。类似的情况也发生在其他一些重要的人类化石上,尤其是出土于内蒙古萨拉乌苏、四川资阳、广西柳江、广东马坝、重庆龙骨坡等遗址的化石材料,致使相关的研究和讨论无法建立在坚实的材料与数据的基础上。

关键词: 元谋人;牙齿;直立人;古地磁;年代

Abstract: The discovery of two teeth of Homo erectus yuanmounensis from the Yuanmou Basin in Yunnan Province, South China, 50 years ago is an important event in the history of research on human origins and evolution in China and East Asia. The original lithological, biostratigraphic and paleomagnetic analyses placed the human fossil bearing stratum to the early Lower Pleistocene with an age of 1.7 Ma which has become the prevailing viewpoint in China since then. However, this estimate was challenged by some scholars and an age of 0.6-0.7 Ma for the teeth was suggested based on paleontological data and paleomagnetic re-analysis. Recent systematic paleomagnetic investigation on three sections at the site by Zhu et al. reconfirmed the age of 1.7Ma for the Yuanmou Man fossil, and this age is believed to be supported by the Lower Pleistocene mammalian assemblage associated with the human remains and with geological comparisons and correlations. However, the teeth were not excavated systematically from the site and detailed information on taphonomic association with the few unearthed artifacts is absent, which has obscured research and discussion on the age and cultural features of Homo erectus yuanmounensis. The age controversy is not an isolated case for Yuanmou Man as human skeletal remains from Salawusu in Inner Mongolia, Liujiang in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, Maba in Guangdong Province and Longgupo in Chongqi Municipality are all found to be associated with such chronological problems. Multidisciplinary research on these materials and sites and direct AMS 14C dating on some fossils of the late Upper Pleistocene age are necessary in the future.

Key words: Yuanmou; Dentition; Homo erectus; Paleomagnetism; Chronology