人类学学报 ›› 2018, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (02): 159-175.

• 人类学学报 • 上一篇    下一篇

卡氏尖在中国古人类化石中出现及其演化意义

刘武;周蜜;邢松   

  • 出版日期:2018-06-15 发布日期:2018-06-15

Occurrence of Carabelli’s cusp in Chinese hominins and its evolutionary implication

LIU Wu, ZHOU Mi, XING Song   

  • Online:2018-06-15 Published:2018-06-15

摘要: 欧洲与亚洲古人类之间的关系一直是人类演化研究的关注点。基于对化石形态的研究,一些学者认为中国与欧洲古人类之间在更新世中、晚期存在一定程度的基因交流,并提供了支持基因交流的系列形态证据,但古人类学界对其中一些形态特征的人群属性、功能意义及形成机制存在不同认识。本文采用釉质外表观察和CT扫描方法对卡氏尖在98枚中国古人类上颌臼齿化石的出现和表现情况进行了数据统计和分析,并与非洲和欧洲古人类进行了对比。本研究发现卡氏尖在中国古人类具有较高的出现率(27.6%-62.5%)和多种形态表现。此外,在多枚中国古人类上颌臼齿发现两个通常只出现在在黑猩猩和非洲早期人类的原始卡氏尖表现:齿带-原尖脊和齿冠舌侧横行沟及屋檐状结构。基于这些发现,作者支持卡氏尖是从猿类,经过不同演化阶段的古人类,一直延续到现代人的一个古老特征的观点。卡氏尖在中国古人类的表现特点提示出现在中国古人类的卡氏尖更有可能是古老原始特征的残余。本研究显示,卡氏尖在中国与欧洲古人类都具有较高出现率,而卡氏尖在中国古人类的表现程度较同时期欧洲古人类更为显著。因此目前还没有足够的可信证据支持卡氏尖是中国与欧洲古人类之间基因交流的造成化石形态特征。

关键词: 卡氏尖;牙齿;化石;人类演化;基因交流

Abstract: The relationship between hominins in Europe and Asia has been the concern of human evolutionary studies for a while. Based on morphological studies of hominin fossils, some researchers believe that there was gene flow between these hominins during the Middle and Late Pleistocene based on morphological evidence. However there have been different understandings of some of aspects of population affinity, function, development and homology. In this research, occurrences and expression patterns of Carabelli’s cusp of 98 upper molars of Chinese hominins were analyzed in both the outer enamel surface (OES) and enamel dentine junction (EDJ) based on micro-CT scanning. Comparisons with the specimens of African and European hominins were also considered. Our results show that Carabelli’s cusp has a high frequency in Chinese hominins (27.6%~62.5%) including different expression patterns, specifically the cingulum-protocone crest and horizontal groove across the crown lingual surface or shelf-like Carabelli’s cusp, which usually occur in chimpanzee and African early hominins but are also identified in a number of upper molars of Chinese hominins. With these results, we support the view that Carabelli’s cusp is an ancient or primitive feature that evolved from apes until modern humans. The expression patterns of Carabelli’s cusp in Chinese hominins suggest that this trait is possibly a remnant of the ancient or primitive feature. This study shows that Carabelli’s cusp has a high frequency in both Chinese and European hominins but is more pronounced in Chinese hominins than its European counterparts. Therefore, there is no reliable evidence to currently support Carabelli’s cusp as a morphological feature indicative of gene flow between Chinese and European hominins.

Key words: Carabelli’s cusp; Dentition; Paleoanthropology; Gene flow