日本旧石器晚期石器技术起源的新考古学与人类学证据
收稿日期: 2021-05-11
修回日期: 2021-11-11
网络出版日期: 2024-06-05
On the beginning of the Japanese Upper Paleolithic: A review of recent archaeological and anthropological evidence
Received date: 2021-05-11
Revised date: 2021-11-11
Online published: 2024-06-05
Supported by
JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers 18H03596(PI: Yosuke Kaifu);JP19H01336(PI: Hiroyuki Sato);21H00608(PI: Kazuki Morisaki)
对日本旧石器时代晚期开端的探讨主要通过两种模式展开，即列岛内旧石器时代中期演化模式和大陆旧石器时代晚期扩散或迁徙模式，然而，最近来自日本和周边国家的考古学证据正对这种简单的模式提出挑战。本文批判性地回顾了包括可能存在的早中期在内的日本旧石器时代已有年代序列，并尝试展示有关日本旧石器时代晚期开端的另一种模式。本文列举了一些可能属于旧石器时代早中期的发现，并建议进一步开展地质考古研究，以了解其可信度以及与旧石器时代晚期早段（EUP）之间的文化关系。目前，日本EUP的开端以距今约3.9-3.7万年前古本州岛具有台形石器和锯齿刃器的石片工业为特征。尽管台形石器仅流行于日本EUP阶段，并且可能源自岛内更早的石器传统，但这一石器工业也在一定程度上显示出与同时期中国和朝鲜半岛石器组合的相似之处。石叶技术最早出现于古本州岛中部，比最早的石片技术晚了约1000年。虽然石叶技术可能起源于前一时期的长石片技术，但突然性的同时出现也可能意味着这一技术由朝鲜半岛扩散而来。本文认为，由于区域适应策略的不同，源自朝鲜半岛的石叶技术进入到古本州岛东北部，包括本州西部的日本海沿岸地区，而不是石片技术长期盛行的西南地区。
Hiroyuki SATO , Kazuki MORISAKI . 日本旧石器晚期石器技术起源的新考古学与人类学证据[J]. 人类学学报, 2024 , 43(03) : 470 -487 . DOI: 10.16359/j.1000-3193/AAS.2022.0043
The beginning of the Japanese Upper Paleolithic has mainly been examined using two major models: the Middle Paleolithic evolutionary model within the archipelago and the continental Upper Paleolithic diffusion/migration model. However, recent archeological data from Japan and nearby countries are challenging such simple models. This paper critically reviews previous chronology of the Japanese Paleolithic, including possible Lower and Middle Paleolithic (LP/MP), and attempts to show an alternative model of the beginning of the Japanese Upper Paleolithic. This paper suggests several possible specimens of LP/MP and recommends further geoarchaeological investigation to understand the reliability and cultural relationship between possible LP/MP specimens and the Early Upper Paleolithic (EUP). The start of the Japanese EUP is presently characterized by a flake industry with trapezoids and denticulates around 39-37 kaBP cal on Paleo-Honshu Island, which has partial resemblance with contemporary assemblages in China and the Korean Peninsula, although trapezoids are endemic only to the Japanese EUP and may have derived from the ancestral lithic tradition. Blade technology appeared earliest on Central Paleo-Honshu Island, about 1000 years later than the earliest flake technology. Although blade technology may have originated from the elongated flake technology of the previous period, the sudden simultaneous emergence implies that it diffused from the Korean Peninsula. This paper proposes that blade technology from the Korean Peninsula arrived on the northeastern Paleo-Honshu Island, including the Japan Sea coastal region of western Honshu, rather than the southwest, where flake technology long prospered, due to differences in ecological settings and adaptation strategies between the two regions.
| [1] | Li F, Vanwezer N, Boivin N, Gao X, et al. Heading north: Late Pleistocene environments and human dispersals in central and eastern Asia. PLoS ONE, 2019, 14(5): e0216433 |
| [2] | Kaifu Y, Izuho M, Goebel T. Modern human dispersal and behavior in Paleolithic Asia:summary and discussion. In: Kaifu Y, Izuho M, Goebel T, Sato H (Eds.). Emergence and Diversity of Modern Human Behavior in Palaeolithic Asia. Texas: Texas A&M University Press, 2015: 535-566 |
| [3] | Zwyns N, Paine CH, Tsedendorj B, et al. The Northern Route for Human dispersal in Central and Northeast Asia: New evidence from the site of Tolbor-16, Mongolia. Scienctific Reports, 2019, 9(1): 11759 |
| [4] | Izuho M, Kaifu Y. The appearance and characteristics of the early Upper Palaeolithic in the Japanese Archipelago. In: Kaifu Y, Izuho M, Goebel T, Sato H (Eds.). Emergence and Diversity of Modern Human Behavior in Palaeolithic Asia. Texas: Texas A&M University Press, 2015: 289-313 |
| [5] | Sato H. Recent advances of the Initial Upper Palaeolithic study in Asia: Estimating the lithic assemblages of third and fourth cultural layers in the Locality 6 of the Suyanggae Site. Journal of the Korean Palaeolithic Society, 2017, 35: 5-20 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [6] | Sato H. Formation process of territoriality and prehistoric societies in Upper Palaeolithic Kyushu and Hokkaido. In: Yoshidome Hidetoshi shi Tsuito Ronshu Kankokai (Ed.). Isekigaku no Chihei [Perspectives on Archaeological Site Research]. Fukuoka: Yoshidome Hidetoshi shi Tsuito Ronshu Kankokai, 2020: 1-8 (in Japanese) |
| [7] | Morisaki K, Sano K, Izuho M. Early Upper Paleolithic blade technology in the Japanese Archipelago. Archaeological Research in Asia, 2019, 17: 79-97 |
| [8] | Anzai M, Sato H. Transition from Middle to Upper Palaeolithic in Japan. In:Proceedings of the International Symposium ‘Chronostratigraphy of Paleolithic of North, Central, East Asia and America (Paleoecological Aspect). Novosibirsk: Soviet Scientific Academy Siberian Branch, 1990: 97-105 |
| [9] | Matsufuji K. Study of the Origin of the Upper Palaeolithic Culture in the Japanese Archipelago. Osaka: Kyowa Press Inc, 2004: 1-143 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [10] | Tamura T. Neighbors, not auslanders: some thoughts on the appearance of laminar technologies in the Japanese Archipelago. Quarterly of Archaeological Studies, 2015, 61(4): 24-44 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [11] | Kunitake S, Sutou T, Tsutsumi T. The assemblage and the origin of the oldest blade industryin the Japanese Archipelago. Kyusekki Kenkyu [Palaeolithic Research], 2021, 17: 125-146 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [12] | Morisaki K, Kunikita D, Ikeda T, et al. Ishinomoto revisited: A chronological study on the beginning of the Upper Palaeolithic Period in the Japanese Archipelago. Kyusekki Kenkyu [Palaeolithic Research], 2020, 16: 43-58 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [13] | Kudo Y. Environment and culture history of the Upper Palaeolithic and the Jomon Period: high-precision radiocarbon dating and archaeology. Tokyo: Shinsensha, 2012, 1-373 (in Japanese) |
| [14] | Takahara H, Hayashi R. Paleovegetation during Marine Isotope Stage 3 in East Asia. In: Kaifu Y, Izuho M, Goebel T, Sato H (Eds.). Emergence and Diversity of Modern Human Behavior in Palaeolithic Asia. Texas: Texas A&M University Press, 2015, 314-324 |
| [15] | Lambeck K, Roubya H, Anthony P, et al. Sea level and global ice volumes from the Last Glacial Maximum to the Holocene. PNAS, 2014, 111-43: 15296-15303 |
| [16] | Sato H. Chinese, Korean, and Japanese Palaeolithic.In: Executive Committee of Iwajuku Forum (Ed.). Proceedings of the 7th Iwajuku Forum. Gunma: Kasakake-cho Board of Education, 1999: 37-43 (in Japanese) |
| [17] | Matsui H, Tada R, Oba T. Low-salinity isolation event in the Japan Sea in response to eustatic sea-level drop during LGM: reconstruction based on salinity-balance model. Daiyonki Kenkyu [The Quaternary Research], 1998, 37: 221-233 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [18] | Yoo DG, Lee GS, Kim GY, et al. Seismic stratigraphy and depositional history of late Quaternary deposits in a tide-dominated setting: An example from the eastern Yellow Sea. Marine and Petroleum Geology, 2016, 73: 212-227 |
| [19] | Sato H. A perspective on the Middle Paleolithic study of the East Asia. In: Derevianko AP, Shunkov MV (Eds.). Proceedings of the International Symposium “Early Human Habitation of Central, North and East Asia: Archaeological and Paleoecological Aspects”. Novosibirsk: Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography Press, 2005: 161-171 |
| [20] | Iwase A, Hashizume J, Izuho M, et al. The timing of megafaunal extinction in the late Late Pleistocene on the Japanese Archipelago. Quaternary International, 2012, 255: 114-124 |
| [21] | Sato H, Yamada S, Izuho M. Terrestrial resources and hunting activity in Upper Palaeolithic in Japanese Islands. In: Sato H, Iinuma K (Eds.). No to Hara no Kankyoshi [Environmental History of Grassland in the Japanese Archipelago]. Tokyo: Bun-ichi Sogo Shuppan, 2011: 51-72 (in Japanese) |
| [22] | Morisaki K, Izuho M, Terry K, et al. Lithics and climate: technological responses to landscape change in Upper Palaeolithic northern Japan. Antiquity, 2015, 89(345): 554-572 |
| [23] | Takahashi K, Izuho M. Formative history of terrestrial fauna of the Japanese Islands during the Plio-Pleistocene. In: Ono A, Izuho M (Eds.). Environmental Changes and Human Occupation in East Asia during OIS3 and OIS2 (BAR International Series 2352). Oxford: British Archaeological Reports Ltd, 2012: 73-86 |
| [24] | Sato H. Trap-pit hunting in Late Pleistocene Japan. In: Kaifu Y, Izuho M, Goebel T, Sato H (Eds.). Emergence and Diversity of Modern Human Behavior in Palaeolithic Asia. Texas: Texas A&M University Press, 2015: 389-405 |
| [25] | Yamazaki S. Palaeolithic humans and coastal subsistence: a view from the margin. Palaeolithic Kyushu, 2020, 24: 223-246 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [26] | Sato H. The framework of the Upper Palaeolithic cultures in the Japanese Archipelago, and Hokkaido and Kyushu Island. Kyushu Kyusekki [Palaeolithic Kyushu], 2000, 4: 71-82 (in Japanese) |
| [27] | Sato H. Early Upper Paleolithic Industries in Hokkaido, Japan. In: Деревянко АП (Ed.). Проблемы Археологии и Палеоэкологии Северной и Центральной Азии. Novosibirsk: Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography Press, 2003: 243-246 |
| [28] | Kaifu Y, Fujita M, Yoneda M, et al. Pleistocene seafaring and colonization on the Ryukyu Islands, Southwestern Japan. In: Kaifu Y, Izuho M, Goebel T, Sato H (Eds.). Emergence and Diversity of Modern Human Behavior in Palaeolithic Asia. Texas: Texas A&M University Press, 2015: 345-361 |
| [29] | Fujita M, Yamasaki S, Sawaura R. The migration, culture and lifestyle of the Paleolithic Ryukyu Islanders. In: Ono R, Pawlik A, (Eds.). Pleistocene Archaeology- Migration, Technology, and Adaptation. London: IntechOpen (open access eBook), 2020: 1-15 |
| [30] | Sato H. Recent research on the Early and Middle Palaeolithic in Japan: an overview. Bulletin of the Society for East Asian Archaeology, 2016, 3: 29-35 |
| [31] | Yoshikawa S, Kawamura Y, Taruno H. Land bridge formation and proboscidean immigration into the Japanese Islands during the Quaternary. Journal of Geosciences, Osaka City University, 2007, 50(1): 1-6 |
| [32] | Sato H. Human behavior responses to environmental and resource fluctuation in the Pleistocene Japanese Archipelago. In: Tanaka Yoshiyuki Sensei Tsuito Ronshu Kankokai (Ed.). Archaeology: Is it Science? Fukuoka: Chugoku-Shoten, 2016: 199-214 (in Japanese) |
| [33] | Komura H. Aichi ken kaseizawa ky?sekki jidai iseki [The Kaseizawa Palaeolithic Site]. Tokyo: Genbunsha, 1968, 1-61 (in Japanese) |
| [34] | Sato H. Emergence of east Asian Upper Palaeolithic. Ibou, 2008, 26: 2-15 (in Japanese) |
| [35] | Sato H. Re-examination of Middle/Upper Palaeolithic transition in the Japanese Archipelago. Al-RāFIDāN, 2017, 38: 55-60 (in Japanese) |
| [36] | Kikuchi K (Ed.). Kanedori iseki [Kanedori Site]. Iwate: Miyamori Village Board of Education, 1986: 1-61 (in Japanese) |
| [37] | Kuroda A (Ed.). Kanedori iseki: dai 2·3 ji hakkutsu ch?sa h?kokusho [The 2nd and 3rd Excavation Report of Kanedori Site]. Iwate: Miyamori Village Board of Education, 2005: 1-132 (in Japanese) |
| [38] | Kikuchi K (Ed.). Kashiyamatate ato hakkutsu ch?sa h?kokusho [Excavation Report of Kashiyamatate site]. Iwate: Iwate Prefectural Archaeology Center, 1996: 1-295 (in Japanese) |
| [39] | Japanese Palaeolithic Research Association. Paleolithic Sites in the Japanese Islands: A Database. Tokyo: Japanese Palaeolithic Research Association, 2010: 1-377 (in Japanese) |
| [40] | Nakazawa Y. On the Pleistocene population history in the Japanese Archipelago. Current Anthropology, 2017, 58: S539-S552 |
| [41] | Sato H. Kyusekki Jidai: Nihon Bunka no Hajimari [Palaeolithic Period: Emergence of Japanese Culture]. Tokyo: Keibun-Sha, 2019: 1-127 (in Japanese) |
| [42] | Naoe Y, Nagasaki J. Lithic raw material consumption strategy of the Early Upper Paleolithic in Hokkaido. Hokkaido Kyusekki Bunka Kenkyu [Paleolithic Culture Research in Hokkaido] 2005, 10: 45-58 (in Japanese) |
| [43] | Izuho M, Akai F. Geochronology of Palaeolithic sites in Hokkaido, Japan. Kyusekki Kenkyu [Palaeolithic Research] 2005, 1: 39-55 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [44] | Terasaki Y. The Chronology of Paleolithic in Hokkaido. In: Anzai M, Sato H (Eds.). Kyusekki Jidai no Chiiki Hennenteki Kenkyu [Regional Chronological Studies of the Paleolithic Period in the Japanese Archipelago]. Tokyo: Doseisha, 2006: 275-314 (in Japanese) |
| [45] | Izuho M, Kunikita D, Nakazawa Y, et al. New AMS dates from the Shukubai-Kaso site (Loc. Sankakuyama), Hokkaido (Japan): Refining the chronology of small flake-based assemblages during the Early Upper Palaeolithic in the Palaeo-Sakhalin-Hokkaido-Kurile Peninsula. PaleoAmerica, 2018, 4(2): 134-150 |
| [46] | Izuho M, Morisaki K, Oda N, et al. Surface collections from Akita 10 site. In: Sato H (Ed.). Research on the Relationships between Human and Environmental Fluctuation in the Northern Circum Japan Sea Area (NCJSA) in Late Pleistocene. Hokkaido: University of Tokyo, 2011, 98-121 (in Japanese) |
| [47] | Oda N, Morisaki K. Recent problems surrounding the Early Upper Palaeolithic site of Akita 10, Hokkaido, Japan. Kyusekki Kenkyu [Paleolithic Research], 2016, 12: 217-225 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [48] | Nakazawa Y, Izuho M, Takakura J, et al. Toward an Understanding of Technological Variability in Microblade Assemblages in Hokkaido, Japan. Asian Perspectives, 2005, 44: 276-292 |
| [49] | Sato H, Tsutsumi T. The Japanese microblade industries:technology, raw material procurement and adaptation. In: Kuzmin Y, Keats S, Shen C (Eds.). Origin and Spread of Microblade Technology in Northern Asia and North America. Burnaby, BC: SFU Archaeology Press, 2007: 53-78 |
| [50] | Kudo Y, Kumon F. Palaeolithic cultures of MIS3 to MIS1 in Relation to Climate Changes in the Central Japanese Islands. Quaternary International, 2012, 248: 22-31 |
| [51] | Ikeda T (Ed.). Isinomoto isekigun II [Ishinomoto Sites II]. Kumamoto: Kumamoto Prefecture Board of Education, 1999: 1-226 (in Japanese) |
| [52] | Harada Y (Ed.). Idemaruyama iseki hakkutsu chosa hokokusho [Excavation Report of Idemaruyama Site]. Shizuoka: Numazu City Board of Education, 2011: 1-120 (in Japanese) |
| [53] | Machida H, Arai F. Atlas of Tephra in and around Japan (Revised Edition). Tokyo: The University of Tokyo Press, 2003: 1-360 (in Japanese) |
| [54] | Oda S, Keally CT. Japanese Paleolithic Cultural Chronology; Occasional Papers 2. Tokyo: Archaeological Research Center, International Christian University, 1975 |
| [55] | Shibutani A. Starch residues on stone tools from the Tachikiri, Kakuriyama, Soujiyama and Okunonita Sites: Material. Kodai Bunka [Cultura Antiqua], 2008, 60(1): 130-140 (in Japanese) |
| [56] | Sato H. Three Paleolithic cultures in the Japanese Archipelago. In: Saidin M, Lee YJ, Woo JY (Eds.). Proceedings of the 23rd Suyanggae International Symposium in Malaysia “Suyanggae and Lenggong: Prehistory Adaptation” Penang: Organization Committee, 2018. 23-33 |
| [57] | Nakaza H (Ed.). Report on Survey Excavation of the Shiraho-Saonetabaru Cave Site. Okinawa: Okinawa Prefectural Archaeology Center, 2017: 1-201 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [58] | Sato H. Pleistocene burials and cemetery:new discovery at the Shiraho-saonetabaru Cave Site, Ishigaki Island in the southernmost Japan. In: Nakamura S, Adachi T, Abe M (Eds.). Decades in Deserts: Essays on Near Western Archaeology in Honor of Sumio Fujii. Tokyo: Rokuichi-Shobo, 2019: 357-362 |
| [59] | Sato T, Nakagome S, Watanabe C, et al. Genome-wide SNP analysis reveals population structure and demographic history of the Ryukyu islanders in the southern part of the Japanese archipelago. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 2014, 31: 2929-2940 |
| [60] | Ikeya N. Maritime transport of obsidian in Japan during the Upper Paleolithic. In: Kaifu Y, Izuho M, Goebel T, Ono A (Eds.). Emergence and Diversity of ModernHuman Behavior in Paleolithic Asia. Texas A & M University Press, College Station, 2015: 362-375 |
| [61] | Sato H. Chronological significance and human behavior of the third cultural layer in the Ushiromuta Site. In Tachibana M, Sato H, Yamada S (Eds.). Research Report of the Ushiromuta Site. Miyazaki: Kawaminami-cho Board of Education, 2002: 382-395 (in Japanese) |
| [62] | Kato S. The Paleolithic of China: Its industries and chronology. Kyusekki Kenkyu [Palaeolithic Research], 2019, 15: 91-105 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [63] | Li F, Kuhn SL, Bar-Yosef O, et al. History, Chronology and Techno-Typology of the Upper Paleolithic Sequence in the Shuidonggou Area, Northern China. Journal of World Prehistory, 2019, 32: 111-141 |
| [64] | Nagai K. Lithic industries during the past 50,000 years in Korean Peninsula: Evaluating the radiocarbon chronology of the middle to upper Paleolithic Transition. Kyusekki Kenkyu [Palaeolithic Research], 2016, 12: 185-206 (in Japanese with English abstract) |
| [65] | Sudo T (Ed.). Happusan iseki gun [Happusan Sites]. Nagano: Saku City Board of Education, 1999, 1-619 (in Japanese) |
| [66] | Zwyns N, Gladyshev S, Tabarev A, et al. Mongolia:Paleolithic. In: Smith C (Ed.). Encyclopedia of Global Archeology Vol.8. New York: Springer-Verlag, 2014, 5025-5032 |
| [67] | Zwyns N, Lbova LV. The Initial Upper Paleolithic of Kamenka site, Zabaikal region (Siberia): A closer look at the blade technology. Archaeological Research in Asia, 2019, 17: 24-49 |
| [68] | Lee HJ, Lee SS. Chronology and characteristics of the Upper Palaeolithic blade tool industry in Korea. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 2019, 38(3): 373-388 |
| [69] | Lee GK. The characteristics of Upper Paleolithic industries in Korea. In: Kaifu Y, Izuho M, Goebel T, Sato H (Eds.). Emergence and Diversity of Modern Human Behavior in Palaeolithic Asia. Texas: Texas A&M University Press, 2015: 270-286 |
| [70] | Han CG. The Yongho-dong site and Palaeolithic culture. Daejeon Munhwa, 2002, 11: 91-105 (in Korean) |
| [71] | Seong C. Evaluating radiocarbon dates and Late Palaeolithic chronology in Korea. Arctic Anthropology, 2011, 48(1): 93-112 |
| [72] | Choi BK, Ryu HJ. Pocheon Hwadaeri Shimteo Guseokki Yujeok [The Hwadaeri Shimteo Paleolithic Site. Pocheon City, Korea]. Chuncheon: Doseochulpan Sanchaek, 2005 (in Korean) |
| [73] | Lee YJ, Woo JY. Suyanggae:why so important? In: Derevianko AP, Drozdov NI (Eds.). Topocal issues of the Asian Paleolithic. Novosibirsk: Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography Press, 2014: 129-135 |
| [74] | Lee YJ, Woo JY, Lee SW, et al. Report on the Excavation of Suyanggae Site (Loc.I and VI), Danyang. Cheougju: Institute of Korean Prehistory, 2018: 1-821 (in Korean with English and Japanese abstract) |
| [75] | Morisaki K. Structural Changes and Regional Adaptation of Palaeolithic Society. Tokyo: Rokuichi-Shobo, 2010: 1-262 (in Japanese) |
| [76] | Morisaki K. The evolution of lithic technology and human behavior from MIS 3 to MIS 2 in the Japanese Upper Paleolithic. Quaternary International, 2012, 248: 56-69 |
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |
京ICP证05002819号-3