Physical types and ethnological characteristics of Tibetans

doi:10.16359/j.1000-3193/AAS.2022.0020

Abstract

Abstract:

The physique types and ethnological characteristics of Tibetans have always been concerned by academia. According to the statistics of 1530 cases of Weizang Tibetan, Kham Tibetan and Amdo Tibetan measured in 2018, 2019 and 2021, it was found that Tibetan men and women were all super-medium stature, overweight, and all brachycephaly, hypsicephalic, metriocephalic, mesorrhiny, middle trunk, wide chest, wide shoulders, wide pelvis, mesatiskelic, most of them have eyefold of upper eyelid and mongoloid fold. Analysis of the average principal component of 15 Chinese ethnic measurement indicators shows that the location between Tibetans and Han ethnic group of the East Asian is closer than most of North Asian ethnic groups, and the location of Tibetans is closer to most South Asian ethnic groups. The main component analysis chart of East Asian, South Asian, North Asian and Arctic type data in Tibetan data and foreign data shows that Tibetans are the closest to East Asian-type. Research has confirmed that contemporary Tibetans have the characteristics of Mongolian East Asian-type constitution.

Key words: Tibetan, physique, enthnology, Mogolian

CLC Number:

Q984

LI Yonglan, YU Keli, ZHANG Xinghua, BAO Jinping, LI Chong, ZHENG Lianbin. Physical types and ethnological characteristics of Tibetans[J]. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 2022, 41(04): 698-711.

Figures/Tables 8

References 30

[1]	席焕久. 西藏藏族人类学研究[M]. 北京: 科学技术出版社, 2009
[2]	张振标. 藏族的体质特征[J]. 人类学学报, 1985, 4(3): 250-258
[3]	海向军, 戴玉景. 中国藏族头面部特征研究[J]. 卫生职业教育, 2005, 23(19): 120-122
[4]	温有锋, 叶丽平, 胡荣, 等. 西藏藏族起源初探-来自掌指纹的线索[J]. 人类学学报, 2011, 30(1): 102-108
[5]	李海军, 徐晓娜. 青海土族和藏族侧面部轮廓形状及其变异:基于标志点的几何形态测量分析[J]. 科学通报, 2014, 59(16): 1516-1524
[6]	胡兴宇, 吴国雄, 汪澜, 等. 对甘肃省玛曲县境内安多藏族青壮年体质特征的调查研究[J]. 泸州医学院学报, 1991, 14(2): 102-106
[7]	席焕久, 陈昭. 人体测量方法[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2010
[8]	Oladipo GS, Okoh PD, Isong EE. Anthropometric Studies of Cephalic Length, Cephalic Breadth and Cephalic Indices of the Ibibios of Nigeria[J]. Asian Journal of Medical ences, 2010, 2(3): 104-106
[9]	Bogin B, Varela-Silva MI. Leg Length, Body Proportion, and Health: A Review with a Note on Beauty[J]. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, 2010, 7(3): 1047-1075 doi: 10.3390/ijerph7031047 URL
[10]	Gabriela V, Nathalia A, Mariana F, et al. SUN-252 Comparison of Sitting Height/Height Ratio for Age in Children with Short Stature Caused by Defects in Growth Plate Genes[J]. Journal of the Endocrine Society, 2019, 3(S1): SUN-252
[11]	Dewangan KN, Prasanna Kumar GV, Suja PL, et al. Anthropometric dimensions of farm youth of the north eastern region of India[J]. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 2005, 35(11): 979-989 doi: 10.1016/j.ergon.2005.04.003 URL
[12]	Jung SG, Kim GH, Roh WJ. Comparison of basic body dimension betweenKorean andAmerican for design application[J]. Korean Society of Basic Design and Art, 2000, 1(2): 65-75
[13]	Moss S, Wang Z, Salloum M, et al. Anthropometry for WorldSID, a world-harmonized midsize male side impact crash dummy[R]. Washington, DC: Government/Industry Meeting, 2000, 109:2297-2307
[14]	康龙丽. 西藏各民族遗传多样性研究[M]. 西安: 西安交通大学出版社, 2020
[15]	Qin ZD, Yang YJ, Kang LL, et al. The Genographic Consortium. A Mitochondrial Revelation of Early Human Migrations to the Tibetan Plateau Before and After the Last Glacial Maximum[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol, 2010, 143(4): 555-569 doi: 10.1002/ajpa.21350 URL
[16]	陈锋. 西藏世居人群的母系遗传多样性和夏尔巴人遗传特征[D]. 咸阳: 西藏民族学院, 2014
[17]	包金萍, 宇克莉, 李咏兰, 等. 卫藏藏族与康巴藏族的Heath-Carter法体型[J]. 人类学学报, 2021, 40(5): 834-846
[18]	Zhang M, Yan S, Pan W, et al. Phylogenetic evidence for Sino-Tibetan origin in northern China in the Late Neolithic[J]. Nature, 2019: 1
[19]	Sagart L, Jacques G, Lai Y, et al. Dated language phylogenies shed light on the ancestry of Sino-Tibetan[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2019, 116(21): 10317-10322
[20]	Wang CC, Yeh HY, Popov AN, et al. Genomic insights into the formation of human populations in East Asia[J]. Nature, 2021, 591: 413-419 doi: 10.1038/s41586-021-03336-2 URL
[21]	Wang LX, Lu Y, Zhang C, et al. Reconstruction of Y-chromosome Phylogeny Reveals Two Neolithic Expansions of Tibeto-Burman Populations[J]. Molecular Genetics and Genomics, 2018, 293(5): 1293-1300 doi: 10.1007/s00438-018-1461-2 URL
[22]	李辉, 金雯俐. 人类起源与迁徙之谜[M]. 上海: 上海科技教育出版社, 2020
[23]	刘武, 杨茂有, 王野城. 现代中国人颅骨测量特征及其地区性差异的初步研究[J]. 人类学学报, 1991, 10(2): 96-105
[24]	鲁东胜. 基于二代测序数据分析的人类群体基因组学研究[D]. 北京: 中国科学院大学, 2016
[25]	雅•雅•罗金斯基, 马•格•列文. 人类学[M]. 北京: 警官教育出版社, 1993
[26]	Deng L, Zhang C, Yuan K, et al. Prioritizing natural-selection signals from the deep-sequencing genomic data suggests multi-variant adaptation in Tibetan highlanders[J]. National Science Review, 2019, 6(6): 1201-1222 doi: 10.1093/nsr/nwz108 URL
[27]	吴新智, 崔娅铭. 过去十万年里的四种人及其间的关系[J]. 科学通报, 2016, 24: 7
[28]	Li YC, Tian JY, Liu FW, et al. Neolithic millet farmers contributed to the permanent settlement of the Tibetan Plateau by adopting barley agriculture[J]. National Science Review, 2019, 6(5): 1006-1013
[29]	龚凌霄. 青稞全谷物及其防治代谢综合征的作用研究[D]. 杭州: 浙江大学, 2013
[30]	韩康信, 张君. 藏族体质人类学特征及其种族源[J]. 文博, 1991, 6: 6-15

测量指标Index	男性Male					女性Female					u
测量指标Index	卫藏Weizang	康巴Kham	安多Amdo	合计Total	F	卫藏Weizang	康巴Kham	安多Amdo	合计Total	F	u
头长L_head	198.9±6.5	195.9±6.9	188.5±6.8	194.7±8.1^abc	152.910^**	188.9±6.4	186.5±6.2	176.8±6.4	184.7±8.1^abc	213.943^**	24.14^**
头宽B_head	160.3±5.9	156.9±5.2	155.3±6.2	157.7±6.2^abc	46.956^**	154.5±5.5	150.5±4.9	147.9±5.5	151.3±5.9^abc	87.227^**	20.66^**
面宽B_face	152.1±5.8	149.9±4.8	146.8±5.5	149.8±5.9^abc	58.772^**	144.0±5.1	141.9±5.0	138.5±5.3	141.7±5.6^abc	61.071^**	27.51^**
下颌角间宽B_big	118.3±5.4	115.2±5.2	115.9±6.8	116.7±6.0^ac	18.052^**	112.1±5.6	109.9±5.6	108.0±5.2	110.2±5.7^abc	30.253^**	21.7^**
眼内角间宽B_inter	33.9±2.8	36.1±3.0	34.5±2.9	34.6±3.0^abc	33.669^**	32.9±2.6	34.4±3.8	33.3±2.7	33.6±3.1^bc	15.045^**	6.41^**
鼻宽B_nose	38.1±2.9	38.7±3.5	38.7±3.2	38.4±3.2^ac	3.289^*	34.1±2.6	35.4±2.8	34.6±2.7	34.7±2.7^bc	14.816^**	24.38^**
口宽B_mou	50.4±4.0	50.0±4.2	51.7±3.8	50.7±4.0^ab	11.125^**	47.8±3.3	47.7±3.7	47.7±3.4	47.7±3.5	0.144	15.58^**
容貌面高H_phy-fac	195.7±9.8	192.6±7.7	199.9±9.3	196.4±9.6^abc	30.017^**	183.1±8.8	183.1±8.1	187.6±8.4	184.3±8.7^ab	19.368^**	25.79^**
形态面高H_mor-fac	123.7±7.5	125.2±6.2	126.5±6.3	125.0±6.9^abc	11.023^**	114.2±6.1	117.3±5.9	118.2±6.5	116.4±6.4^ac	26.698^**	25.24^**
鼻高H_nas	48.9±3.4	53.5±3.5	56.5±3.9	52.6±4.9^abc	288.698^**	44.3±4.0	49.8±3.3	50.9±3.7	48.1±4.7^abc	217.899^**	18.32^**
鼻长L_nas	45.3±3.6	49.6±4.0	49.3±3.9	47.7±4.3^ac	102.036^**	39.4±3.6	45.7±3.2	44.4±3.8	43.0±4.5^abc	223.791^**	20.89^**
上唇皮肤部高H_up-Lip	16.4±2.9	16.9±3.3	15.4±3.6	16.2±3.3^ab	10.973^**	14.9±2.5	15.7±2.9	15.7±3.1	15.4±2.8^ac	6.950^**	5.10^**
唇高H_lip	13.6±3.8	14.4±3.6	16.7±4.1	14.8±4.0^abc	39.773^**	13.1±3.5	14.4±3.3	15.5±3.7	14.2±3.6^abc	26.847^**	3.08^**
红唇厚度L_thi	6.0±1.9	6.5±2.0	8.1±2.0	6.8±2.2^abc	70.219^**	5.9±1.7	6.7±1.9	7.5±1.9	6.6±2.0^abc	43.980^**	1.86
耳上头高H_aur	127.7±10.2	128.9±10.8	125.7±4.4	127.3±9.0^ab	23.750^**	125.4±10.3	119.9±10.4	124.5±5.2	123.2±9.6^bc	33.750^**	8.62^**
体质量m	73.7±12.4	70.8±11.8	75.3±13.3	73.4±12.6^bc	7.820^**	63.9±12.0	60.7±9.9	62.6±9.6	62.9±10.6^bc	2.255	17.59^**
身高S	1667.8±64.5	1683.3±61.6	1682.4±56.6	1675.7±61.9^ac	3.945^**	1556.6±60.5	1564.3±59.5	1559.9±58.8	1560.6±59.1	1.505	37.16^**
坐高H_sit	878.1±39.0	884.1±37.9	899.3±36.8	887.1±39.3^ab	18.809^**	828.3±37.1	827.9±38.1	845.9±38.6	834.4±37.9^ab	13.139^**	26.68^**
肩宽B_sho	383.4±18.3	379.7±17.1	400.6±21.5	388.3±21.2^abc	70.867^**	350.1±16.1	347.6±15.9	362.2±16.7	352.6±17.3^ab	48.142^**	35.98^**
骨盆宽B_cre-ili	306.4±15.2	285.2±18.2	304.2±21.2	300.5±20.2^bc	74.088^**	304.5±17.3	285.9±17.3	299.8±19.4	296.6±19.6^abc	70.404^**	3.83^**
上肢全长L_up-ex	740.0±37.3	741.9±33.4	748.3±38.5	743.7±36.8^a	2.823	684.4±37.3	685.4±35	691.9±35.6	686.6±35.8^a	2.823	30.74^**
下肢全长L_low-ex	871.8±39.8	907.9±38.5	879.9±40.3	884.1±42.4^ab	13.450^**	843.9±35.9	855.9±37.2	841.9±33.6	848.3±36.6^bc	13.248^**	17.64^**
胸围C_che	964.6±77.9	966.5±73.5	944.2±73.7	957.9±75.7^ab	5.616^**	914.0±88.7	911.7±71.8	887.1±68.6	910.4±78.9^ab	12.496^**	12.02^**
腰围C_wai	897.4±101.3	896.1±87.7	909.4±102.2	901.3±98.8	1.147	833.8±102.7	805.6±93.8	822.0±92.4	825.5±97.4^c	1.737	15.10^**
臀围C_hip	988.6±63.5	980.5±60.5	981±72.6	983.7±65.8	1.505	990.8±89.6	961.3±72.1	950.3±59.5	972.8±78.3^ac	15.711^**	2.95^**
全臂长L_arm	557.6±31.0	557.3±29.3	562.1±32.6	559.6±31.2	7.585^**	512.2±30.5	506.5±31.6	518.3±30.7	511.9±31.0^abc	7.585^**	29.98^**
全腿长L_leg	810.5±40.5	839.6±38.3	829.0±41.5	824.5±42.1^abc	0.903	784.1±36.3	787.1±38.0	786.7±34.9	786.4±36.7	0.903	18.83^**

测量指标Index	男性Male					女性Female					u
测量指标Index	卫藏Weizang	康巴Kham	安多Amdo	合计Total	F	卫藏Weizang	康巴Kham	安多Amdo	合计Total	F	u
头长L_head	198.9±6.5	195.9±6.9	188.5±6.8	194.7±8.1^abc	152.910^**	188.9±6.4	186.5±6.2	176.8±6.4	184.7±8.1^abc	213.943^**	24.14^**
头宽B_head	160.3±5.9	156.9±5.2	155.3±6.2	157.7±6.2^abc	46.956^**	154.5±5.5	150.5±4.9	147.9±5.5	151.3±5.9^abc	87.227^**	20.66^**
面宽B_face	152.1±5.8	149.9±4.8	146.8±5.5	149.8±5.9^abc	58.772^**	144.0±5.1	141.9±5.0	138.5±5.3	141.7±5.6^abc	61.071^**	27.51^**
下颌角间宽B_big	118.3±5.4	115.2±5.2	115.9±6.8	116.7±6.0^ac	18.052^**	112.1±5.6	109.9±5.6	108.0±5.2	110.2±5.7^abc	30.253^**	21.7^**
眼内角间宽B_inter	33.9±2.8	36.1±3.0	34.5±2.9	34.6±3.0^abc	33.669^**	32.9±2.6	34.4±3.8	33.3±2.7	33.6±3.1^bc	15.045^**	6.41^**
鼻宽B_nose	38.1±2.9	38.7±3.5	38.7±3.2	38.4±3.2^ac	3.289^*	34.1±2.6	35.4±2.8	34.6±2.7	34.7±2.7^bc	14.816^**	24.38^**
口宽B_mou	50.4±4.0	50.0±4.2	51.7±3.8	50.7±4.0^ab	11.125^**	47.8±3.3	47.7±3.7	47.7±3.4	47.7±3.5	0.144	15.58^**
容貌面高H_phy-fac	195.7±9.8	192.6±7.7	199.9±9.3	196.4±9.6^abc	30.017^**	183.1±8.8	183.1±8.1	187.6±8.4	184.3±8.7^ab	19.368^**	25.79^**
形态面高H_mor-fac	123.7±7.5	125.2±6.2	126.5±6.3	125.0±6.9^abc	11.023^**	114.2±6.1	117.3±5.9	118.2±6.5	116.4±6.4^ac	26.698^**	25.24^**
鼻高H_nas	48.9±3.4	53.5±3.5	56.5±3.9	52.6±4.9^abc	288.698^**	44.3±4.0	49.8±3.3	50.9±3.7	48.1±4.7^abc	217.899^**	18.32^**
鼻长L_nas	45.3±3.6	49.6±4.0	49.3±3.9	47.7±4.3^ac	102.036^**	39.4±3.6	45.7±3.2	44.4±3.8	43.0±4.5^abc	223.791^**	20.89^**
上唇皮肤部高H_up-Lip	16.4±2.9	16.9±3.3	15.4±3.6	16.2±3.3^ab	10.973^**	14.9±2.5	15.7±2.9	15.7±3.1	15.4±2.8^ac	6.950^**	5.10^**
唇高H_lip	13.6±3.8	14.4±3.6	16.7±4.1	14.8±4.0^abc	39.773^**	13.1±3.5	14.4±3.3	15.5±3.7	14.2±3.6^abc	26.847^**	3.08^**
红唇厚度L_thi	6.0±1.9	6.5±2.0	8.1±2.0	6.8±2.2^abc	70.219^**	5.9±1.7	6.7±1.9	7.5±1.9	6.6±2.0^abc	43.980^**	1.86
耳上头高H_aur	127.7±10.2	128.9±10.8	125.7±4.4	127.3±9.0^ab	23.750^**	125.4±10.3	119.9±10.4	124.5±5.2	123.2±9.6^bc	33.750^**	8.62^**
体质量m	73.7±12.4	70.8±11.8	75.3±13.3	73.4±12.6^bc	7.820^**	63.9±12.0	60.7±9.9	62.6±9.6	62.9±10.6^bc	2.255	17.59^**
身高S	1667.8±64.5	1683.3±61.6	1682.4±56.6	1675.7±61.9^ac	3.945^**	1556.6±60.5	1564.3±59.5	1559.9±58.8	1560.6±59.1	1.505	37.16^**
坐高H_sit	878.1±39.0	884.1±37.9	899.3±36.8	887.1±39.3^ab	18.809^**	828.3±37.1	827.9±38.1	845.9±38.6	834.4±37.9^ab	13.139^**	26.68^**
肩宽B_sho	383.4±18.3	379.7±17.1	400.6±21.5	388.3±21.2^abc	70.867^**	350.1±16.1	347.6±15.9	362.2±16.7	352.6±17.3^ab	48.142^**	35.98^**
骨盆宽B_cre-ili	306.4±15.2	285.2±18.2	304.2±21.2	300.5±20.2^bc	74.088^**	304.5±17.3	285.9±17.3	299.8±19.4	296.6±19.6^abc	70.404^**	3.83^**
上肢全长L_up-ex	740.0±37.3	741.9±33.4	748.3±38.5	743.7±36.8^a	2.823	684.4±37.3	685.4±35	691.9±35.6	686.6±35.8^a	2.823	30.74^**
下肢全长L_low-ex	871.8±39.8	907.9±38.5	879.9±40.3	884.1±42.4^ab	13.450^**	843.9±35.9	855.9±37.2	841.9±33.6	848.3±36.6^bc	13.248^**	17.64^**
胸围C_che	964.6±77.9	966.5±73.5	944.2±73.7	957.9±75.7^ab	5.616^**	914.0±88.7	911.7±71.8	887.1±68.6	910.4±78.9^ab	12.496^**	12.02^**
腰围C_wai	897.4±101.3	896.1±87.7	909.4±102.2	901.3±98.8	1.147	833.8±102.7	805.6±93.8	822.0±92.4	825.5±97.4^c	1.737	15.10^**
臀围C_hip	988.6±63.5	980.5±60.5	981±72.6	983.7±65.8	1.505	990.8±89.6	961.3±72.1	950.3±59.5	972.8±78.3^ac	15.711^**	2.95^**
全臂长L_arm	557.6±31.0	557.3±29.3	562.1±32.6	559.6±31.2	7.585^**	512.2±30.5	506.5±31.6	518.3±30.7	511.9±31.0^abc	7.585^**	29.98^**
全腿长L_leg	810.5±40.5	839.6±38.3	829.0±41.5	824.5±42.1^abc	0.903	784.1±36.3	787.1±38.0	786.7±34.9	786.4±36.7	0.903	18.83^**

指数Index	男性Male					女性Female					u
指数Index	卫藏Weizang	康巴Kham	安多Amdo	合计Total	F	卫藏Weizang	康巴Kham	安多Amdo	合计Total	F	u
头长宽 I_len-bre-h	80.6±3.6	80.2±3.7	82.5±4.6	81.1±4.1^ab	20.914^**	81.8±3.2	80.8±3.3	83.8±4.4	82.0±3.8^abc	37.830^**	4.45^**
头长高 I_len-hei-h	64.3±5.2	66.0±5.9	66.8±3.4	65.5±5.0^ac	16.409^**	66.4±5.5	64.3±5.9	70.5±3.7	66.8±5.7^abc	74.980^**	4.75^**
头宽高 I_bre-hei-h	79.9±6.5	82.3±7.2	81.0±3.8	80.8±6.0^abc	8.214^**	81.2±6.6	79.7±7.3	84.2±4.3	81.5±6.6^abc	27.137^**	2.17^*
形态面 I_mor-fac	81.4±5.4	83.6±4.8	86.3±5.3	83.6±5.6^abc	55.110^**	79.4±4.5	82.8±4.5	85.4±5.4	82.3±5.3^abc	88.903^**	4.66^**
鼻I_nas	78.3±8.4	72.5±7.1	68.8±6.6	73.6±8.6^abc	101.166^**	77.7±8.7	71.4±7.2	68.3±6.7	72.9±8.6^abc	89.048^**	1.59
口I_lip	27.2±8.0	29.2±8.0	32.4±8.3	29.4±8.4^ab	24.945^**	27.5±7.7	30.4±7.5	32.7±8.3	30.0±8.1^abc	24.756^**	1.42
容貌耳 I_phy-ear	53.6±4.8	52.8±5.7	51.5±4.0	52.7±4.9^ab	11.379^**	51.7±5.0	50.1±6.0	50.7±4.8	50.9±5.3^ac	6.414^**	6.90^**
身高坐高 I_sta-sit-h	52.7±1.5	52.6±1.6	53.5±1.4	52.9±1.5^ab	19.764^**	53.2±1.8	53.0±1.4	54.2±1.6	53.5±1.7^ab	29.751^**	7.33^**
身高体质量I_sta-we	441.1±67.6	419.8±64.4	446.7±73.4	437.2±69.3^bc	9.268^**	410.3±72.2	387.7±60.6	400.9±58.8	402.6±64.8^c	2.975^**	10.07^**
身高胸围 I_sta-ch-c	57.8±4.5	57.5±4.5	56.1±4.3	57.2±4.5^ab	8.976^**	58.8±5.8	58.3±5.0	56.9±4.7	58.4±5.3^ab	10.268^**	4.78^**
身高肩宽 I_sta-sh-bre	23.0±1.0	22.6±0.9	23.8±1.1	23.2±1.1^abc	74.294^**	22.5±1.0	22.2±0.9	23.2±1.0	22.6±1.0^abc	64.389^**	11.15^**
身高骨盆宽I_sta-cri-ili	18.4±0.9	17.0±1.1	18.1±1.2	17.9±1.2^abc	86.782^**	19.6±1.1	18.3±1.2	19.2±1.4	19.0±1.4^abc	71.412^**	16.53^**
肩宽骨盆宽I_acr-cri	80.0±4.5	75.2±5.0	76.0±4.9	77.5±5.2^ac	66.739^**	87.1±5.1	82.4±5.3	82.9±5.3	84.2±5.7^ac	59.023^**	24.04^**
马氏躯干腿长I_{Man's- ske}	90.0±5.4	90.3±5.8	87.2±5.0	89.0±5.5^ab	19.655^**	88.0±6.3	88.9±5.0	84.5±5.2	87.2±5.8^ab	30.608^**	6.23^**
身高上肢长I_sta-up-L-L	44.4±1.6	44.1±1.5	44.5±1.6	44.4±1.6	0.855	44.0±1.8	43.9±1.6	44.4±1.8	44.0±1.7^ab	6.690^**	4.74^**
身高下肢长I_sta-low-L-L	52.3±1.9	54.1±2.8	52.3±1.7	52.8±2.2^bc	51.966^**	54.2±1.7	54.8±1.8	54.0±1.7	54.4±1.8^bc	12.559^**	15.52^**
身体质量指数I_mas	26.4±3.9	24.9±3.7	26.5±4.2	26.1±4.0^bc	10.384^**	26.5±4.8	24.7±3.9	25.7±3.8	25.8±4.2^c	3.778^**	1.43

指数Index	男性Male					女性Female					u
指数Index	卫藏Weizang	康巴Kham	安多Amdo	合计Total	F	卫藏Weizang	康巴Kham	安多Amdo	合计Total	F	u
头长宽 I_len-bre-h	80.6±3.6	80.2±3.7	82.5±4.6	81.1±4.1^ab	20.914^**	81.8±3.2	80.8±3.3	83.8±4.4	82.0±3.8^abc	37.830^**	4.45^**
头长高 I_len-hei-h	64.3±5.2	66.0±5.9	66.8±3.4	65.5±5.0^ac	16.409^**	66.4±5.5	64.3±5.9	70.5±3.7	66.8±5.7^abc	74.980^**	4.75^**
头宽高 I_bre-hei-h	79.9±6.5	82.3±7.2	81.0±3.8	80.8±6.0^abc	8.214^**	81.2±6.6	79.7±7.3	84.2±4.3	81.5±6.6^abc	27.137^**	2.17^*
形态面 I_mor-fac	81.4±5.4	83.6±4.8	86.3±5.3	83.6±5.6^abc	55.110^**	79.4±4.5	82.8±4.5	85.4±5.4	82.3±5.3^abc	88.903^**	4.66^**
鼻I_nas	78.3±8.4	72.5±7.1	68.8±6.6	73.6±8.6^abc	101.166^**	77.7±8.7	71.4±7.2	68.3±6.7	72.9±8.6^abc	89.048^**	1.59
口I_lip	27.2±8.0	29.2±8.0	32.4±8.3	29.4±8.4^ab	24.945^**	27.5±7.7	30.4±7.5	32.7±8.3	30.0±8.1^abc	24.756^**	1.42
容貌耳 I_phy-ear	53.6±4.8	52.8±5.7	51.5±4.0	52.7±4.9^ab	11.379^**	51.7±5.0	50.1±6.0	50.7±4.8	50.9±5.3^ac	6.414^**	6.90^**
身高坐高 I_sta-sit-h	52.7±1.5	52.6±1.6	53.5±1.4	52.9±1.5^ab	19.764^**	53.2±1.8	53.0±1.4	54.2±1.6	53.5±1.7^ab	29.751^**	7.33^**
身高体质量I_sta-we	441.1±67.6	419.8±64.4	446.7±73.4	437.2±69.3^bc	9.268^**	410.3±72.2	387.7±60.6	400.9±58.8	402.6±64.8^c	2.975^**	10.07^**
身高胸围 I_sta-ch-c	57.8±4.5	57.5±4.5	56.1±4.3	57.2±4.5^ab	8.976^**	58.8±5.8	58.3±5.0	56.9±4.7	58.4±5.3^ab	10.268^**	4.78^**
身高肩宽 I_sta-sh-bre	23.0±1.0	22.6±0.9	23.8±1.1	23.2±1.1^abc	74.294^**	22.5±1.0	22.2±0.9	23.2±1.0	22.6±1.0^abc	64.389^**	11.15^**
身高骨盆宽I_sta-cri-ili	18.4±0.9	17.0±1.1	18.1±1.2	17.9±1.2^abc	86.782^**	19.6±1.1	18.3±1.2	19.2±1.4	19.0±1.4^abc	71.412^**	16.53^**
肩宽骨盆宽I_acr-cri	80.0±4.5	75.2±5.0	76.0±4.9	77.5±5.2^ac	66.739^**	87.1±5.1	82.4±5.3	82.9±5.3	84.2±5.7^ac	59.023^**	24.04^**
马氏躯干腿长I_{Man's- ske}	90.0±5.4	90.3±5.8	87.2±5.0	89.0±5.5^ab	19.655^**	88.0±6.3	88.9±5.0	84.5±5.2	87.2±5.8^ab	30.608^**	6.23^**
身高上肢长I_sta-up-L-L	44.4±1.6	44.1±1.5	44.5±1.6	44.4±1.6	0.855	44.0±1.8	43.9±1.6	44.4±1.8	44.0±1.7^ab	6.690^**	4.74^**
身高下肢长I_sta-low-L-L	52.3±1.9	54.1±2.8	52.3±1.7	52.8±2.2^bc	51.966^**	54.2±1.7	54.8±1.8	54.0±1.7	54.4±1.8^bc	12.559^**	15.52^**
身体质量指数I_mas	26.4±3.9	24.9±3.7	26.5±4.2	26.1±4.0^bc	10.384^**	26.5±4.8	24.7±3.9	25.7±3.8	25.8±4.2^c	3.778^**	1.43

指标Index	分型 Somatotype	卫藏Weizang		康巴Kham		安多Amdo		u1	u2	u3
指标Index	分型 Somatotype	例数n	占比%	例数n	占比%	例数n	占比%	u1	u2	u3
发型S_hair	直发straight	424	81.5%	367	97.6%	398	97.1%	6.57^**	7.83^**	12.82^**
发型S_hair	波发wave	82	15.8%	9	2.4%	12	2.9%	8.54^**	6.36^**	1.52
上眼睑皱褶F_up-eye	无no	95	18.2%	147	31.3%	126	30.7%	2.82^**	4.59^**	2.05^*
上眼睑皱褶F_up-eye	有yes	425	81.6%	322	68.7%	284	69.3%	9.11^**	3.86^**	4.71^**
内眦褶F_mon	无no	354	67.9%	188	40.7%	282	68.8%	11.70^**	0.65	11.53^**
内眦褶F_mon	有yes	166	31.9%	274	59.3%	128	31.2%	5.15^**	0.03	4.81^**
眼裂高度H_ope-eye	狭窄narrow	161	30.9%	116	29.3%	103	25.1%	4.17^**	1.78	2.07^*
	中等middle	338	64.9%	237	59.8%	296	72.2%	7.92^**	2.73^**	10.01^**
	较宽wide	18	3.5%	43	10.9%	11	2.7%	2.86^**	0.63	3.16^**
眼裂倾斜度D_eye	内角高internal angle	4	0.8%	21	5.6%	1	0.2%	3.17^**	1.07	3.51^**
	水平middle	180	34.5%	122	32.4%	185	45.1%	5.02^**	3.48^**	8.26^**
	外角高external angle	335	64.3%	234	62.1%	224	54.6%	7.90^**	2.66^**	4.70^**
鼻根高度H_nas-r	低平low	161	30.9%	124	26.1%	135	32.9%	3.61^**	0.83	4.24^**
	中等middle	347	66.6%	297	62.4%	269	65.6%	5.15^**	0.04	4.82^**
	较高high	12	2.3%	55	11.6%	6	1.5%	4.97^**	0.89	5.10^**
鼻背侧面观P_nas	凹型concave	139	26.7%	35	7.3%	74	18.0%	9.37^**	2.97^**	6.06^**
	直型straight	330	63.3%	386	80.9%	276	67.3%	1.06	1.61	0.66
	凸型protruding	51	9.8%	56	11.7%	60	14.6%	0.08	2.36^**	2.51^*
下颏类型J_und	后缩型 retraction	54	10.4%	34	8.6%	23	5.6%	2.76^**	2.54^*	0.10
	直型straight	146	28.0%	111	28.0%	248	60.5%	3.49^**	10.15^*	13.53^**
	凸型protruding	323	62.0%	252	63.5%	139	33.9%	6.12^**	8.22^**	2.79^**
上唇皮肤部高H_up-Lip	低low	25	4.8%	24	6.0%	42	10.2%	0.54	3.27^**	3.88^**
	中等middle	451	86.7%	325	80.6%	313	76.3%	10.90^**	3.41^**	6.91^**
	高high	50	9.6%	54	13.4%	55	13.4%	0.17	1.92	2.14^*
红唇厚度L_thi	薄唇thin	435	83.7%	281	69.6%	186	45.4%	12.02^**	11.79^**	0.68
	中唇middle	88	16.9%	114	28.2%	188	45.9%	1.17	9.77^**	9.00^**
	厚唇thick	3	0.6%	9	2.2%	36	8.8%	1.55	6.26^**	5.45^**
鼻宽B_nose	窄narrow	41	7.9%	118	29.4%	33	8.0%	5.86^**	0.18	5.18^**
	中等middle	283	54.4%	218	54.2%	207	50.5%	5.55^**	0.89	4.28^**
	宽wide	202	38.8%	66	16.4%	170	41.5%	10.56^**	1.04	11.10^**