A comparison of head and facial characteristics between the Daur ethnic groups in Inner Mongolia and Xinjiang

doi:10.16359/j.1000-3193/AAS.2024.0061

Abstract

Abstract:

In this study, 629 healthy Daur adults (315 males and 314 females) from Molidavar Autonomous Banner (referred to as Moqi) of Hulunbuir, Inner Mongolia and Tacheng City of Xinjiang were selected as research objects. 40 head and face indexes were investigated, and 5 head and face indexes and their subtypes were calculated. The data were processed by SPSS20.0 statistical software and R software.Research has found that there is a significant difference in the head and facial features of adults between the Daur ethnic group in Inner Mongolia and the Daur ethnic group in Xinjiang. The average value of each index of Daur nationality in Xinjiang is higher than that of Daur nationality in Inner Mongolia. Inner Mongolia Daur adults have longer head, wider head, wider face, narrower nose and lower nose. The adults of Daur nationality in Xinjiang have the facial features of medium length and width of head, narrow nose and low nose，which may be related to the geographical environment and communication and integration between populations.This study provides a reference for exploring the reasons and rules of the evolution of phenotypic characteristics between Daur ethnic groups and exploring the origin relationship of Daur ethnic groups.

Key words: Daur, head and face, morphological features, Physical Anthropology

CLC Number:

Q984

LI Xin, JIANG Shuai, HUANG Ting, ZHONG Hua, WEN Youfeng. A comparison of head and facial characteristics between the Daur ethnic groups in Inner Mongolia and Xinjiang[J]. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 2024, 43(04): 586-596.

Figures/Tables 8

References 38

[1]	杨圣敏. 中国民族志[M]. 北京: 中央民族大学出版社, 2003, 128-136
[2]	徐兴锐, 白絮飞, 苏福荣. 达斡尔族人迁徙至黑龙江流域的原因新探[J]. 边疆经济与文化, 2020, 4: 6-9
[3]	赵凤彩. 达斡尔族人口简析[J]. 人口学刊, 1991, 3: 50-53
[4]	类维顺, 王嘉昕. 达斡尔族“传统摇篮”的艺术特征与民俗文化研究[J]. 文艺争鸣, 2024, 2: 204-208
[5]	沙仁高娃, 程慧珍, 韦兰海. 达斡尔语分支早期在蒙古语族中的地位[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(6): 1037-1046
[6]	吕洋. 达斡尔族人类起源神话“天神抟土造人”与“洪水后生人神话”内涵探析[J]. 内蒙古学院学报, 2020, 28(1): 21-24
[7]	包羽, 伊乐泰. 达斡尔族历史上的萨满教疾病观[J]. 中国民族医药杂志, 2019, 25(3): 65-68
[8]	施全德, 胡俊清, 杨宏友. 黑龙江省达斡尔族体质特征调查[J]. 人类学学报, 1983, 2(1): 60-71
[9]	朱钦, 季晓君. 达斡尔族学生的体质发育与体型[J]. 人类学学报, 1993, 12(1): 71-79
[10]	朱钦, 富杰, 刘文忠, 等. 达斡尔族成人的体格、体型及半个多世纪来的变化[J]. 人类学学报, 1996, 15(2): 119-126
[11]	邓文涛, 姜东, 席焕久, 等. 辽宁锡伯族成人头面部体质特征[J]. 解剖学杂志, 2019, 42(2): 177-182
[12]	李强, 李欣, 买尔旦江·莫合塔尔, 等. 阿克陶县塔吉克族成人头面部表型特征[J]. 解剖学报, 2022, 53(3): 360-366 doi: 10.16098/j.issn.0529-1356.2022.03.014
[13]	李欣, 李强, 张文虔, 等. 新疆不同地区柯尔克孜族成人容貌特征差异[J]. 解剖学杂志, 2020, 43(3): 220-225 doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-1633.2020.03.009
[14]	李咏兰, 刘璐. 中国蒙古族头面部的体质人类学特征[J]. 解剖学报, 2019, 50(1): 98-106 doi: 10.16098/j.issn.0529-1356.2019.01.017
[15]	张咸鹏. 辽宁满族人群体质特征及遗传结构研究[D].硕士学位毕业论文, 锦州: 锦州医科大学, 2022
[16]	孙思凡. 广西瑶族体质特征及遗传特征研究[D].硕士学位毕业论文, 呼和浩特: 内蒙古师范大学, 2021
[17]	珠娜. 水族体质特征及遗传特征研究[D].硕士学位毕业论文, 呼和浩特: 内蒙古师范大学, 2021
[18]	张咸鹏, 温有锋, 李文慧, 等. 中国阿尔泰语系人群头面部的表型特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2023, 42(3): 342-358
[19]	刘小元, 温有锋, 叶丽平, 等. 满-通古斯语族人群头面部特征比较[J]. 解剖学报, 2018, 49(2): 251-257 doi: 10.16098/j.issn.0529-1356.2018.02.019
[20]	席焕久, 陈昭(主编). 人体测量方法[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2010
[21]	刘学峰. 辽宁汉族成人头面部形态特征[D].硕士学位毕业论文, 锦州: 辽宁医学院, 2011
[22]	邵兴周, 崔静, 朱新安, 等. 新疆特克斯县柯尔克孜族表型特征[J]. 人类学学报, 1987, 6(4): 315-323
[23]	宇克莉, 李咏兰, 张兴华, 等. 维吾尔族体质类型:来自喀什的资料[J]. 中国科学(生命科学), 2020, 50(9): 983-995
[24]	李晶, 李珊, 宇克莉, 等. 羌族的表型特征[J]. 解剖学杂志, 2018, 41(4): 440-445, 486
[25]	廉祎. 中国苗族的体质类型和人种学特征[D].硕士学位毕业论文, 呼和浩特: 内蒙古师范大学, 2023
[26]	张兴华, 郑连斌, 宇克莉, 等. 西双版纳傣族头面部形态特征的年龄变化[J]. 南京师大学报(自然科学版), 2016, 39(1): 79-85
[27]	严明亮. 基于人体测量学的新疆蒙古族察哈尔部、土尔扈特部的人类生物学研究[D].硕士学位毕业论文, 呼和浩特: 内蒙古师范大学, 2020
[28]	廉伟. 土尔扈特人体质人类学与分子遗传学研究[D].硕士学位毕业论文, 呼和浩特: 内蒙古师范大学, 2017
[29]	张君瑞. 巴尔虎蒙古族体质人类学与人类群体遗传学研究[D].硕士学位毕业论文, 呼和浩特: 内蒙古师大学, 2016
[30]	刘海萍. 云南蒙古族表型特征与群体遗传学特征性研究[J]. 内蒙古师范大学, 2007, 18(3): 40-42
[31]	杜传书, 刘祖洞. 医学遗传学[M]. 北京: 人民卫生出版社, 1983, 755-756
[32]	Steegmann AT Jr. Climate, racial category, and body proportions in the US[J]. American Journal of Human Biology, 2010, 17(4): 393-402
[33]	Luojinsky YY, Levin MG. Anthropology[M]. Beijing: Police Education Press, 1993, 525-528
[34]	Vernot B, Akey JM. Complex history of admixture between Modern Humans and Neandertal[J]. Am J Hum Genet, 2015, 96(3): 448-453
[35]	Cui W, Jin XY, Guo YX, et al. Forensic applicability of autosomal insertion/ deletion loci in Chinese Duar ethnic group and genetic affinity evaluations between Daur group and reference populations[J]. Leg Med (Tokyo), 2020, 47: 101741
[36]	Chen LK. The compendium of ethnic history in China[M]. Beijing: Financial＆Econo-mic press, 2008, 20(3): 3-8
[37]	Wang CZ, Su MJ, Li Y, et al. Genetic polymorphisms of 27 Yfiler Plus loci in the Daur and Mongolian ehtnic minorities from Hulunbuir of Inner Mongolia Autonom- ous Region, China[J]. Forensic Sci Int Genet, 2019, 40: 252-255
[38]	吴秀杰, 刘武, 张全超, 等. 中国北方全新世人群头面部形态特征的微观演化[J]. 科学通报, 2007, 52(2): 192-198

指标Index	类型Type	内蒙古NMG		新疆XJ		合计Total
		男Male	女Female	男Male	女Female	内蒙古NMG	新疆XJ
发旋H_vortex	S型S type	45.3%**	10.8%	87.3%	92.9%	27.6%^＃＃	90.0%
	Z型Z type	14.7%**	7.0%	9.1%	3.9%	10.7%^＃＃	6.6%
	SS型SS type	1.3%**	1.3%	0.6%	0.6%	1.3%^＃＃	0.6%
	ZZ型ZZ type	0.7%**	0.0%	0.0%	0.6%	0.3%^＃＃	0.3%
	SZ型SZ type	5.3%**	0.0%	1.8%	0.0%	2.6%^＃＃	0.9%
	扩散型Diffusion type	32.7%**	81.0%	1.2%	1.9%	57.5%^＃＃	1.6%
头发类型F_hair	直发Lissotrichous	83.3%	78.5%	97.6%	94.8%	80.8%^＃＃	96.3%
	波发Kymatotrichous	15.3%	17.1%	1.2%	3.9%	16.2%^＃＃	2.5%
	卷发Ulotrichous	1.3%	4.4%	1.2%	1.3%	2.9%^＃＃	1.3%
前额发际F_hair-point	尖Apiciform	48.0%	37.3%	84.2%**	71.6%	42.5%^＃＃	78.1%
	否Round	52.0%	62.7%	15.8%**	28.4%	57.5%^＃＃	21.9%
颧部突出度P_zygomatic	扁平Flat	8.7%*	13.9%	6.1%**	22.6%	11.4%^＃＃	14.1%
	中等Medium-sized	57.3%*	64.6%	41.8%**	51.6%	61.0%^＃＃	46.6%
	微弱Weak	34.0%*	21.5%	52.1%**	25.8%	27.6%^＃＃	39.4%
下颏T_chin	后斜型Posterior	14.7%	15.2%	10.9%	7.1%	14.9%^＃＃	9.1%
	直型Straight	51.3%	50.6%	38.8%	41.3%	51.0%^＃＃	40.0%
	凸型Convex	34.0%	34.2%	50.3%	51.6%	34.1%^＃＃	50.9%
前额倾斜度D_forehead	后斜Posterior	31.3%**	7.6%	55.2%**	43.2%	19.2%^＃＃	49.4%
	直型Straight	44.7%**	50.6%	34.5%**	45.2%	47.7%^＃＃	39.7%
	前凸Convex	24.0%**	41.8%	10.3%**	11.6%	33.1%^＃＃	10.9%
眉毛B_eye	稀少Rare	11.3%**	38.0%	27.9%**	57.4%	25.0%^＃＃	42.2%
	中等Medium	58.0%**	57.0%	55.8%**	41.9%	57.5%^＃＃	49.1%
	浓密Dense	30.7%**	5.1%	16.4%**	0.6%	17.5%^＃＃	8.8%
眉弓S_eye-arch	弱Thinner	10.0%**	54.4%	36.4%**	63.2%	32.8%^＃＃	49.4%
	中等Medium	66.7%**	42.4%	35.2%**	34.2%	54.2%^＃＃	34.7%
	粗壮Sturdy	23.3%**	3.2%	28.5%**	2.6%	13.0%^＃＃	15.9%
上唇侧面观P_up-lip	凸唇型Convex lip	11.3%	8.9%	40.0%	40.0%	10.1%^＃＃	40.0%
	正唇型Normal lip	62.7%	59.5%	35.8%	40.0%	61.0%^＃＃	37.8%
	缩唇型Shrinkage lip	26.0%	31.6%	24.2%	20.0%	28.9%^＃＃	22.2%
美人沟B_ditch	无Naught	86.7%	87.3%	70.3%**	85.8%	87.0%^＃＃	77.8%
	微弱Low	9.3%	10.8%	20.6%**	11.0%	10.1%^＃＃	15.9%
	明显Deep	4.0%	1.9%	9.1%**	3.2%	2.9%^＃＃	6.3%

指标Index	类型Type	内蒙古NMG		新疆XJ		合计Total
		男Male	女Female	男Male	女Female	内蒙古NMG	新疆XJ
发旋H_vortex	S型S type	45.3%**	10.8%	87.3%	92.9%	27.6%^＃＃	90.0%
	Z型Z type	14.7%**	7.0%	9.1%	3.9%	10.7%^＃＃	6.6%
	SS型SS type	1.3%**	1.3%	0.6%	0.6%	1.3%^＃＃	0.6%
	ZZ型ZZ type	0.7%**	0.0%	0.0%	0.6%	0.3%^＃＃	0.3%
	SZ型SZ type	5.3%**	0.0%	1.8%	0.0%	2.6%^＃＃	0.9%
	扩散型Diffusion type	32.7%**	81.0%	1.2%	1.9%	57.5%^＃＃	1.6%
头发类型F_hair	直发Lissotrichous	83.3%	78.5%	97.6%	94.8%	80.8%^＃＃	96.3%
	波发Kymatotrichous	15.3%	17.1%	1.2%	3.9%	16.2%^＃＃	2.5%
	卷发Ulotrichous	1.3%	4.4%	1.2%	1.3%	2.9%^＃＃	1.3%
前额发际F_hair-point	尖Apiciform	48.0%	37.3%	84.2%**	71.6%	42.5%^＃＃	78.1%
	否Round	52.0%	62.7%	15.8%**	28.4%	57.5%^＃＃	21.9%
颧部突出度P_zygomatic	扁平Flat	8.7%*	13.9%	6.1%**	22.6%	11.4%^＃＃	14.1%
	中等Medium-sized	57.3%*	64.6%	41.8%**	51.6%	61.0%^＃＃	46.6%
	微弱Weak	34.0%*	21.5%	52.1%**	25.8%	27.6%^＃＃	39.4%
下颏T_chin	后斜型Posterior	14.7%	15.2%	10.9%	7.1%	14.9%^＃＃	9.1%
	直型Straight	51.3%	50.6%	38.8%	41.3%	51.0%^＃＃	40.0%
	凸型Convex	34.0%	34.2%	50.3%	51.6%	34.1%^＃＃	50.9%
前额倾斜度D_forehead	后斜Posterior	31.3%**	7.6%	55.2%**	43.2%	19.2%^＃＃	49.4%
	直型Straight	44.7%**	50.6%	34.5%**	45.2%	47.7%^＃＃	39.7%
	前凸Convex	24.0%**	41.8%	10.3%**	11.6%	33.1%^＃＃	10.9%
眉毛B_eye	稀少Rare	11.3%**	38.0%	27.9%**	57.4%	25.0%^＃＃	42.2%
	中等Medium	58.0%**	57.0%	55.8%**	41.9%	57.5%^＃＃	49.1%
	浓密Dense	30.7%**	5.1%	16.4%**	0.6%	17.5%^＃＃	8.8%
眉弓S_eye-arch	弱Thinner	10.0%**	54.4%	36.4%**	63.2%	32.8%^＃＃	49.4%
	中等Medium	66.7%**	42.4%	35.2%**	34.2%	54.2%^＃＃	34.7%
	粗壮Sturdy	23.3%**	3.2%	28.5%**	2.6%	13.0%^＃＃	15.9%
上唇侧面观P_up-lip	凸唇型Convex lip	11.3%	8.9%	40.0%	40.0%	10.1%^＃＃	40.0%
	正唇型Normal lip	62.7%	59.5%	35.8%	40.0%	61.0%^＃＃	37.8%
	缩唇型Shrinkage lip	26.0%	31.6%	24.2%	20.0%	28.9%^＃＃	22.2%
美人沟B_ditch	无Naught	86.7%	87.3%	70.3%**	85.8%	87.0%^＃＃	77.8%
	微弱Low	9.3%	10.8%	20.6%**	11.0%	10.1%^＃＃	15.9%
	明显Deep	4.0%	1.9%	9.1%**	3.2%	2.9%^＃＃	6.3%

指标Index	类型Type	内蒙古NMG		新疆XJ		合计Total
指标Index	类型Type	男Male	女Female	男Male	女Female	内蒙古NMG	新疆XJ
上眼睑皱褶E_up-eye	有Have	34.7%*	48.1%	25.5%	32.3%	41.6%^＃＃	28.8%
	无Naught	65.3%*	51.9%	74.5%	67.7%	58.4%^＃＃	71.3%
蒙古褶F_mon	有Have	77.3%*	64.6%	43.6%	34.8%	70.8%^＃＃	39.4%
	无Naught	22.7%*	35.4%	56.4%	65.2%	29.2%^＃＃	60.6%
眼裂高度H_ope-eye	狭窄Augusty	57.3%*	45.6%	18.8%	16.1%	51.3%^＃＃	17.5%
	中等Moderately	42.7%*	51.3%	60.6%	55.5%	47.1%^＃＃	58.1%
	较宽Relatively brosd	0.0%*	3.2%	20.6%	28.4%	1.6%^##	24.4%
眼裂倾斜度D_eye	内角高Interior angle higher than exterior angle	12.7%*	15.8%	74.5%	81.3%	14.3%^＃＃	77.8%
	水平Horizontal	59.3%*	69.0%	17.6%	14.8%	64.3%^＃＃	16.3%
	外角高Exterior angle higher than interior angle	28.0%*	15.2%	7.9%	3.9%	21.4%^＃＃	5.9%
耳尖T_ear	猕猴型Macaque	2.0%**	1.3%	3.6%	1.9%	1.6%^＃＃	2.8%
	长尾猴型Vervet monkey type	13.3%**	26.6%	33.3%	28.4%	20.1%^＃＃	30.9%
	尖耳尖型Pointed ear tip	0.7%**	1.9%	13.9%	14.8%	1.3%^＃＃	14.4%
	圆耳尖型Round ear tip	16.0%**	24.1%	48.5%	54.8%	20.1%^＃＃	51.6%
	耳尖微显Ear tip microphenotype	14.0%**	15.2%	0.6%	0.0%	14.6%^＃＃	0.3%
	缺耳尖型Tipless	54.0%**	31.0%	0.0%	0.0%	42.2%^＃＃	0.0%
耳垂T_lobe	圆形Round type	26.7%	35.4%	48.5%	52.3%	31.2%^＃＃	50.3%
	方形Square type	36.7%	25.9%	35.8%	32.3%	31.2%^＃＃	34.1%
	三角形Triangular type	36.7%	38.6%	15.8%	15.5%	37.7%^＃＃	15.6%
鼻根高度H_nas-root	低平Low and flat	26.0%**	53.2%	47.9%**	71.6%	39.9%^＃＃	59.4%
	中等Medium sized	47.3%**	39.9%	41.2%**	27.1%	43.5%^＃＃	34.4%
	较高Relatively high	26.7%**	7.0%	10.9%**	1.3%	16.6%^＃＃	6.3%
鼻背侧面观P_nasal	凹型Concavity type	7.3%**	15.8%	28.5%**	47.7%	11.7%^＃＃	37.8%
	直型Straight type	70.7%**	64.6%	45.5%**	31.0%	67.5%^＃＃	38.4%
	凸型Protruding type	15.3%**	18.4%	15.8%**	9.7%	16.9%^＃＃	12.8%
	波型Wave type	6.7%**	1.3%	10.3%**	11.6%	3.9%^＃＃	10.9%
鼻基底方向 D_nose-base	上翘型Upwarp	37.3%**	32.3%	34.5%**	59.4%	34.7%^＃＃	46.6%
鼻基底方向 D_nose-base	水平型Horizontal	31.3%**	48.7%	50.3%**	35.5%	40.3%^＃＃	43.1%
	下垂型Descensus	31.3%**	19.0%	15.2%**	5.2%	25.0%^＃＃	10.3%
鼻孔最大径位置MD_nostrils	水平Transverse	14.7%*	16.5%	17.0%*	26.5%	15.6%	21.6%
鼻孔最大径位置MD_nostrils	倾斜Oblique	66.0%*	52.5%	66.1%*	51.0%	59.1%	58.8%
	矢状Vertical	19.3%*	31.0%	17.0%*	22.6%	25.3%	19.7%

指标Index	类型Type	内蒙古NMG		新疆XJ		合计Total
指标Index	类型Type	男Male	女Female	男Male	女Female	内蒙古NMG	新疆XJ
上眼睑皱褶E_up-eye	有Have	34.7%*	48.1%	25.5%	32.3%	41.6%^＃＃	28.8%
	无Naught	65.3%*	51.9%	74.5%	67.7%	58.4%^＃＃	71.3%
蒙古褶F_mon	有Have	77.3%*	64.6%	43.6%	34.8%	70.8%^＃＃	39.4%
	无Naught	22.7%*	35.4%	56.4%	65.2%	29.2%^＃＃	60.6%
眼裂高度H_ope-eye	狭窄Augusty	57.3%*	45.6%	18.8%	16.1%	51.3%^＃＃	17.5%
	中等Moderately	42.7%*	51.3%	60.6%	55.5%	47.1%^＃＃	58.1%
	较宽Relatively brosd	0.0%*	3.2%	20.6%	28.4%	1.6%^##	24.4%
眼裂倾斜度D_eye	内角高Interior angle higher than exterior angle	12.7%*	15.8%	74.5%	81.3%	14.3%^＃＃	77.8%
	水平Horizontal	59.3%*	69.0%	17.6%	14.8%	64.3%^＃＃	16.3%
	外角高Exterior angle higher than interior angle	28.0%*	15.2%	7.9%	3.9%	21.4%^＃＃	5.9%
耳尖T_ear	猕猴型Macaque	2.0%**	1.3%	3.6%	1.9%	1.6%^＃＃	2.8%
	长尾猴型Vervet monkey type	13.3%**	26.6%	33.3%	28.4%	20.1%^＃＃	30.9%
	尖耳尖型Pointed ear tip	0.7%**	1.9%	13.9%	14.8%	1.3%^＃＃	14.4%
	圆耳尖型Round ear tip	16.0%**	24.1%	48.5%	54.8%	20.1%^＃＃	51.6%
	耳尖微显Ear tip microphenotype	14.0%**	15.2%	0.6%	0.0%	14.6%^＃＃	0.3%
	缺耳尖型Tipless	54.0%**	31.0%	0.0%	0.0%	42.2%^＃＃	0.0%
耳垂T_lobe	圆形Round type	26.7%	35.4%	48.5%	52.3%	31.2%^＃＃	50.3%
	方形Square type	36.7%	25.9%	35.8%	32.3%	31.2%^＃＃	34.1%
	三角形Triangular type	36.7%	38.6%	15.8%	15.5%	37.7%^＃＃	15.6%
鼻根高度H_nas-root	低平Low and flat	26.0%**	53.2%	47.9%**	71.6%	39.9%^＃＃	59.4%
	中等Medium sized	47.3%**	39.9%	41.2%**	27.1%	43.5%^＃＃	34.4%
	较高Relatively high	26.7%**	7.0%	10.9%**	1.3%	16.6%^＃＃	6.3%
鼻背侧面观P_nasal	凹型Concavity type	7.3%**	15.8%	28.5%**	47.7%	11.7%^＃＃	37.8%
	直型Straight type	70.7%**	64.6%	45.5%**	31.0%	67.5%^＃＃	38.4%
	凸型Protruding type	15.3%**	18.4%	15.8%**	9.7%	16.9%^＃＃	12.8%
	波型Wave type	6.7%**	1.3%	10.3%**	11.6%	3.9%^＃＃	10.9%
鼻基底方向 D_nose-base	上翘型Upwarp	37.3%**	32.3%	34.5%**	59.4%	34.7%^＃＃	46.6%
鼻基底方向 D_nose-base	水平型Horizontal	31.3%**	48.7%	50.3%**	35.5%	40.3%^＃＃	43.1%
	下垂型Descensus	31.3%**	19.0%	15.2%**	5.2%	25.0%^＃＃	10.3%
鼻孔最大径位置MD_nostrils	水平Transverse	14.7%*	16.5%	17.0%*	26.5%	15.6%	21.6%
鼻孔最大径位置MD_nostrils	倾斜Oblique	66.0%*	52.5%	66.1%*	51.0%	59.1%	58.8%
	矢状Vertical	19.3%*	31.0%	17.0%*	22.6%	25.3%	19.7%

指标Index	内蒙古NMG		新疆XJ		合计Total
	男Male	女Female	男Male	女Female	内蒙古NMG	新疆XJ
头长L_{head length}	18.40±1.54**	17.79±1.22	18.83±0.93**	18.11±0.87	18.08±1.42^＃＃	18.48±0.97
头宽B_head	15.15±1.30**	14.41±0.97	15.69±0.84**	15.06±0.89	14.77±1.20^＃＃	15.38±0.92
额最小宽B_min-forehead	11.82±1.21**	11.17±0.97	12.69±1.03**	12.39±0.85	11.48±1.14^＃＃	12.55±0.95
耳上头高H_{head-ear ear height}	13.09±1.22**	12.60±1.36	13.01±1.50	12.77±1.61	12.83±1.32	12.90±1.56
头围C_head	56.03±1.98**	55.42±1.74	57.87±1.94**	56.35±1.94	55.72±1.88^＃＃	57.13±2.08
面宽B_face	13.96±1.17**	13.18±1.19	14.79±1.18**	14.19±1.07	13.56±1.24^＃＃	14.50±1.16
容貌面高H_phy-fac	20.36±0.95**	19.60±1.20	19.28±1.14**	18.41±0.94	19.97±1.15^＃＃	18.85±1.13
形态面高H_mor-face	12.16±1.11**	11.24±1.08	13.52±0.89**	12.80±0.82	11.69±1.18^＃＃	13.17±0.93
下颌角间宽B_bigonlal	12.25±1.28**	11.16±1.32	11.53±1.10**	10.96±1.00	11.69±1.41^＃＃	11.25±1.09
眼内角间宽B_inter	3.04±0.50**	2.76±0.51	3.18±0.38	3.18±0.35	2.90±0.52^＃＃	3.18±0.36
眼外角间宽B_exter	9.60±0.70**	9.32±0.78	9.25±0.71**	8.82±0.69	9.46±0.75^＃＃	9.04±0.73
容貌耳长L_ear	6.56±0.78	6.52±0.65	6.92±0.66**	6.53±0.63	6.54±0.72^＃＃	6.73±0.67
容貌耳宽B_ear	3.01±0.46	2.93±0.42	3.14±0.44*	3.02±0.47	2.97±0.44^＃＃	3.08±0.46
口裂宽 B_mouth	5.81±0.69**	5.53±0.66	5.51±0.55**	5.14±0.50	5.67±0.69^＃＃	5.33±0.56
上唇高度H_up-lip	1.69±0.39	1.63±0.42	2.17±0.30**	1.87±0.29	1.66±0.40^＃＃	2.02±0.33
唇高 H_lip	1.55±0.55*	1.41±0.51	1.57±0.44	1.53±0.36	1.48±0.53^＃＃	1.55±0.40
上红唇厚度L_thi-lip	0.57±0.28	0.51±0.27	0.72±0.26	0.70±0.22	0.54±0.28	0.71±0.24
鼻宽B_nasal	3.88±0.46**	3.51±0.43	4.06±0.45**	3.68±0.32	3.69±0.48^＃＃	3.87±0.44
鼻高H_nasal	5.20±0.82**	4.86±0.67	6.76±0.66**	6.38±0.57	5.03±0.76^＃＃	6.57±0.65
鼻长L_nasal	4.35±0.76**	4.05±0.63	6.15±0.69**	5.76±0.56	4.20±0.71^＃＃	5.96±0.66